SPIRE vs SPIRL: Which is right for you?

SPIRE is an open-source framework for building SPIFFE into your deployments. However, SPIRL is a complete, turn-key solution that is scalable, resilient, and extensible, reducing deployment time from years to minutes—offering capabilities not available out-of-the-box with SPIRE.

Background

SPIRE is a framework for building your own identity and workload management system. This often requires significant effort to build and maintain the parts needed for enterprise-scale deployments.

Solution

SPIRL eliminates the effort of deploying and managing workload identities through built-in integrations and centralized management helping teams focus on production readiness and security.

Why SPIRL?

No Assembly Required

SPIRL offers a complete solution for workload identity, including centralized management, visibility, reporting, and integration with existing enterprise tools like Venafi and Active Directory. You can focus on deployment, not development.

Time to production

Most well-funded organizations take 12-24 months from project inception to deploy SPIRE into production. With SPIRL, our typical customer can get into production in less than a quarter!

Less Developer Busy Work

With SPIRL, your engineers won’t need to build and maintain integrations. They can focus on driving your business with the pre-built capabilities SPIRL provides.

Spend your time where it counts

Instead of spending time designing the pieces needed for a successful SPIRE deployment, platform teams using SPIRL can concentrate on securing your infrastructure.

SPIRL vs SPIRE

Scalability & Isolation

Regional architecture that's horizontally scalable. no data replication or east-west traffic, supports many trust domains, and no external dependencies like databases required.

Nested architecture that is difficult to scale while keeping secure, supports only one trust domain, and requires databases and frequent data replication. Data and federation flows with east-west traffic, requiring many firewall exceptions and inbound internet traffic.

Reliability

Built from the ground up for reliability. Fault-tolerant architecture that continues to function in the face of network isolation. Simple, fewer moving pieces, fewer things to break.

Dozens of moving pieces, each with their own failure modes. A chaining (nested) architecture where any broken link in the chain is catastrophic. Many external dependencies.

User Experience

SPIRL takes a centralized, opinionated approach to workload identity management, enforcing consistent key management and node attestation practices across the infrastructure to reduce misconfigurations and enhance security.

SPIRE is a distributed, non-centralized system where workloads must be registered at every level, giving anyone with registration access the power to mint identities across the entire trust domain.

Operational Overhead

Streamlined operations with cloud-native enterprise tools. 

High operational overhead for deployment and management at scale.